MyFox
 

Northton

by northton from the Land of Free Speech

Last Post 2 days, 6 hours Ago


Hello fellow Bloggers!

This is third of eleven installments of:

"How to Be A Real American"

 

That's right, we are discussing Our Bill of Rights (YOUR RIGHTS!).

 

Amendment III

No soldier shall, in time of peace be quartered in any house, without the consent of the owner, nor in time of war, but in a manner to be prescribed by law.

 

This is not the most well known of amendments to the Bill of Rights so here's a little history on how it came to exist and it's importance to the American Revolution.   These are the events as I understand them.  I'm no historical scholar so feel free to correct me.


By the 1750's, many colonists were demanding their freedom from Britain. In angry retaliation, the king and his Parliament passed a Quartering Act mandating that local colonial authorities provide barracks and supplies for the increasing number of British regulars being sent to America to keep the peace and stop the rebellion.   It is notable that Britain already had laws against soldiers encroaching on the rights and customs of regular citizens.  The act of allowing troops to be quartered in their homes must have seemed very unfair.   

Samuel Adams noted that military members followed a different set of laws than the general public and might, with their superior firepower and military training, impose their rules on citizens.   This is exactly what happened.  British soldiers accused of serious crimes, even murder, were allowed go free without punishment.

The colonists were outraged by unjust practices by their own government.  They began to openly rebel against British authority and, after the famous Boston Tea Party in 1773, the port of Boston was closed. Town meetings were banned.  There was a new Quartering Act, one even more intrusive and demanding than the one that preceded it.  It declared that the still-increasing number of British troops being sent to the colonies would not only be housed and fed in private buildings, but would be lodged in the private homes of citizens, whether they liked it or not.  George III wrote, ‘The die is now cast, the colonies must either submit or triumph.

 

In 1774, the First Continental Congress met and passed a resolution stating that the colonies were not bound to honor these Intolerable Acts.   It wasn't long until, in 1776, the Declaration of Independence was signed and America was on the way to becoming the nation we know today.  Colonial Americans had chafed at being forced to provide room and board for British soldiers, and they made sure the new Constitution protected them from such a practice. In fact, more states included this provision in proposed amendments to the Constitution than freedom of speech.


The third amendment was quickly tested in the war of 1812, and quickly abused. When the American Congress declared war against England it said nothing about the quartering of troops. But soon enough, American troops were being quartered in American homes. Still, many if not most of those forced to accept forced billeting appear to have been compensated by the government in Washington when the war was over, and this compensation can be assumed to have been awarded in recognition of the fact that the law had been broken, the Third Amendment violated.

The Civil War brought the Third Amendment to light once again.  The Committee on War Claims estimated that half a million dollars in claims for rent and damage to real estate came from loyal states following the war, and two and a half million from rebel states as a result of troops being quartered on private property.

 

Is the Third Amendment to the Bill of Rights still important today?

Do you know of any recent violations of the Third Amendment? 

What Blog Ye? 

9 Comments |  Add a Comment

Member Comments Total Comments: 9
Page 1 of 1
ThinkTanked read my blog view my photos
Feb 10, 2008 | 9:49 AM

This may be one of the Amendments that have become outdated. The modern military can now set up living facilities in the field and with Meals Ready to Eat (MREs) supplying food to our troops in the field is no longer a problem. Any public or Government property can be used to set up camp. The technology advances in transportation with aircraft also allows our troops in the field to be rotated back to base when necessary.

The only violations I see, is the military can still invade a private residence and do search and seizures, commit murder, and eavesdrop on the occupants of private residences without having to spend the night there or eat the food of the civilians.

Since we have not seen troops at war on U.S. soil since the Civil War, it is hard to say what it will be like and what Constitutional Rights of American citizens will be violated, but from what can be noted from our current Wars overseas the Constitutional Rights of American Citizens would probably be suspended if a war were to occur on U.S. soil again.

northton read my blog view my photos
Feb 10, 2008 | 11:48 AM

I agree about our rights being snatched out from beneath us. "You have the right to shut up. ... Unless we tell you to talk."

Meb452m read my blog
Feb 10, 2008 | 7:24 PM

Possibly out-dated ? This amendment gives property owners rights and some protection from goverment confiscation of their property.That can't be a bad thing !

DaytonaFrank read my blog view my photos
Feb 10, 2008 | 7:48 PM

Well, I imagine that when the British were "quartered" in American homes, they did not treat the American families kindly. To say the least.
A comparison would be how the invading Iraqi army treated the citizens of Kuwait, when they "quartered" themselves in thier homes!

No one should have to stand for that!

DaytonaFrank read my blog view my photos
Feb 10, 2008 | 7:52 PM

I think that really turned the entire populace against the British, and the reason we sing God Bless America, And not God Save The Queen!

DaytonaFrank read my blog view my photos
Feb 10, 2008 | 7:55 PM

Further, our troops in Iraq and elsewhere, would not "quarter" themselves in ANY home unless they were invited.
This amendment still lives!

rexsmom read my blog view my photos
Feb 11, 2008 | 7:30 AM

It's not outdated. We just haven't needed to use it in a while. The threat still exists. The Bill of Rights is timeless.

AC_Cages read my blog view my photos
Feb 11, 2008 | 8:34 AM

3 ways to be a real American.

1. Never speak anything but English while in America!
2. Always pay your taxes and never file for welfare.
3. Turn in any illegals, never give them money, job, or any means to stay here. Never talk to them in anything but English either.

If Americans did these three things out economy would bounce right back and America would be better off.

The 4th rule will never and cant ever be enforeced due to impossibilities of nature.
4th Rule is always vote for an honest politician.
See why it cant happen? Have you ever heard of an honest politician? Neighter have I

northton read my blog view my photos
Feb 11, 2008 | 7:36 PM

I think what is clear is that, if the "need" arises, this amendment will be broken, just like our right to assemble and our right to bear arms, unless we protest it. In other words, "If you give 'em an inch they'll take a mile."

Page 1 of 1


Write your comment below:




northton

I like sharing ideas and ideals in an open forum. I may not like what you have to say but you can still say it here. I try to be fair. I'll often admit that the positions I support have flaws. I detest bloggers who always base their opinions on their political party's rhetoric and never have an original thought. I am neither a Republican or a Democrat. I vote for whoever I think will do the best job of running things. I may be wrong but at least I think with my own brain. I am looking forward to seeing an open debate between Obama and McCain. I think Obama will whip McCain so badly that you wouldn't believe it. I think Rush Limbaugh is the biggest and most dishonest jerk that ever lived. John "New Orleans Deserved It" Hagee is somewhere right alongside him. If you like Limbaugh or Hagee then you're ignorant and you suck. Whatever you think, join the blog! Come and debate! Let the politicians know what the public really thinks on an open forum like mine where free speech cannot be denied!

Member Since: 1/23/2007