The justices refused, without comment, to intervene in the case from San Diego County, where investigators from the District Attorney's Office show up unannounced at applicants' homes and conduct searches that include peeking into closets and cabinets. The visits do not require any suspicion of fraud and are intended to confirm that people are eligible for government aid.
Failure to submit to the searches, which can last an hour, disqualifies applicants from assistance.
The 10-year-old program was challenged by the American Civil Liberties Union on behalf of six single parents who were seeking assistance. The welfare applicants argued that the Fourth Amendment, which prohibits unreasonable searches, protects them from the home visits.
"When the investigator conducts the home inspection, no part of the home is off-limits," they said.
The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, upholding the program, said the Supreme Court in 1971 allowed social workers to visit homes in New York to determine eligibility. The appeals court, in a 2-1 decision, said the visits do not even constitute a search under the Fourth Amendment in part because people are free to turn away the investigators.
In dissent, however, Judge Raymond Fisher said it was unlawful for an investigator from the district attorney's office to go "walking through the applicant's home in search of physical evidence of ineligibility that could lead to criminal prosecution either for welfare fraud or other crimes unrelated to the welfare application."
| Member Comments | Total Comments: 28 |
|
|
Abunai
Nov 28, 2007 | 12:38 PM |
|||||
|
candyaquino
Nov 28, 2007 | 1:12 PM |
|||||
|
LQQKING
Nov 28, 2007 | 1:36 PM |
|||||
|
rexsmom
Nov 28, 2007 | 1:59 PM |
|||||
|
WVALADYBUG
Nov 28, 2007 | 3:37 PM |
|||||
|
rexsmom
Nov 28, 2007 | 3:49 PM |
|||||
|
oldvamp
Nov 28, 2007 | 5:33 PM |
|||||
|
steveincanton
Nov 28, 2007 | 6:05 PM |
|||||
|
thewizard
Nov 28, 2007 | 9:35 PM |
|||||
|
DaytonaFrank
Nov 29, 2007 | 12:21 AM |
|||||
|
RNC08
Nov 29, 2007 | 12:41 PM |
|||||
|
Riley34470
Nov 29, 2007 | 2:44 PM |
|||||
|
Sarge
Nov 29, 2007 | 4:44 PM |
|||||
|
Riley34470
Nov 29, 2007 | 7:27 PM |
|||||
|
ZiggyFla
Nov 29, 2007 | 7:49 PM |
|||||
|
DaytonaFrank
Nov 29, 2007 | 8:30 PM |
|||||
|
davidpatrick344
Nov 29, 2007 | 11:03 PM |
|||||
|
rexsmom
Nov 30, 2007 | 9:07 AM |
|||||
|
stroke53
Nov 30, 2007 | 9:19 AM |
|||||
|
Mater01
Nov 30, 2007 | 2:35 PM |
|||||
|
stroke53
Nov 30, 2007 | 3:00 PM |
|||||
|
davidpatrick344
Nov 30, 2007 | 5:58 PM |
|||||
|
Abunai
Dec 3, 2007 | 7:24 PM |
|||||
|
stroke53
Dec 4, 2007 | 11:47 AM |
|||||
|
shadowdeplaya
Dec 9, 2007 | 4:33 PM |
|||||
|
shadowdeplaya
Dec 9, 2007 | 4:44 PM |
|||||
|
shadowdeplaya
Dec 9, 2007 | 5:05 PM |
|||||
|
shadowdeplaya
Dec 9, 2007 | 5:10 PM |
|||||
|
|||||
I'm a very opinionated blogger bringing you news that I feel is worth talking about.
Member Since: 3/1/2007
RSS:
What is RSS?