MyFox
 

FOX35News-Mornings's Blog

by FOX35News-Mornings from Lake Mary, FL

Last Post 1 day, 10 hours Ago


This post has been edited by an administrator

FROM HULIQ.COM - Jordin Sparks weight becomes source of public discussion. American Idol winner is suggested to lose some weight.

A health commentator has earned the wrath of Jordin Sparks' fans, after suggesting that the young American Idol winner needs to lose weight.

MeMe Roth, of the group National Action Against Obesity, said she has received death threats since appearing on U.S. television and declaring the 17-year-old Arizona native overweight.

"When I look at Jordin I see diabetes, I see heart disease, I see high cholesterol," said Roth. "That's what's so sad about this - she is not the vision of health - she is the vision of 'unhealth.'"

Roth added that while she never called Sparks "obese," and admires the singer's talent and "effervescent personality," she typifies many modern U.S. children who have compromised their health through poor food choices and inactivity.

Roth said "You'll also find Miss Sparks to be quite contradictory. In her latest People Magazine interview, she's declaring to 'love her body' just as it is, while at the same time, in the sidebar, advising other 'plus-size' females on how to dress slim."

FOX 35 wants so know what you think.

What do you think of these comments?

BLOG IT here and we will read some of your comments on FOX 35 news.


16 Comments |  Add a Comment

Member Comments Total Comments: 16
Page 1 of 1
mscsailor read my blog
Jun 8, 2007 | 6:28 AM

Jordin is a pig.

DVS11965 read my blog view my photos
Jun 8, 2007 | 6:58 AM

So an overweight person told to lose weight for heath reasons is news?

Meme Roth, I think your group would be looked at better is you change your name from the negative National Action Against Obesity to a positive like National Agency for a Healthy Life.

We don't always have to be against things, we can actually be for something

transparent read my blog
Jun 8, 2007 | 7:24 AM

I DID NOT HEAR ANYONE WHEN RUBEN WON AMERICAN IDOL AND HE IS TOTALLY OBESE. JORDAN IS YOUNG AND BEAUTIFUL AND LOOKS TO BE BIG BONED TO ME. SHE IS NOT ROLLING WITH FAT AND SHE IS HAPPY WITH HERSELF. IT IS PEOPLE LIKE THE PERSON THAT MADE THIS COMMENT THAT CAUSE GIRLS TO HAVE EATING DISORDERS.

mshears
Jun 8, 2007 | 7:37 AM

i agree with transparent there is nothing wrong with her the people who are thinking she is fat are skinny get over yourselfs my she is young and big but heathy have a ever heard big and beatifull

oliviasmommy
Jun 8, 2007 | 7:38 AM

I'm going to go with "it's because Jordin is female" as the reason that she is getting all this grief about her weight. Ruben Studard got NO GRIEF when he won AI and he was grossly tipping the scales. I would much rather have my daughter look up to her being an average weight for her height, then look up to the ANOREXIC "Paris Hilton's" of today. THAT should be a health concern. Maybe all you "critics" should pay closer attention to her talent and personality than the size of her waste.

DVS11965 read my blog view my photos
Jun 8, 2007 | 8:00 AM

So all of you going against this saying this is because Jordon is a female don't agree that being that much overweight is a health hazzard? You just think it's because she's a woman? I also said Ruben was overweight and needed a diet. Same thing with both Dan and Roseanne and everyone else.

Why do so many people in this country get upset when someone is told they are overweight and it is a health problem and can become worse? Is it because 70% of our country is overweight?

The only people that say she's overweight are skinny. lol that's funny. if you can't see she's overweight, then you need a new perscription for your glasses.

Are you just taking offense to the obvious?

DVS11965 read my blog view my photos
Jun 8, 2007 | 8:02 AM

Oh and if you ask me, it already looks like Jordan has an eating disorder. Eating to much is also an eating disorder. FIMS (fork in mouth sickness) is also an eating disorder, not just bolemia.

Face it being overweight kills more people then cigarettes. Don't believe me? How many 70 and 80 year old people do you know that smoke? How many 70 and 80 year olds do you know that are 100lbs or so overweight? Point proven.

NeZe read my blog view my photos
Jun 8, 2007 | 8:49 AM

Some people are just bigger than others.

I have a 13-year-old son whose 5'8" tall whose built is similar to Jordin's. He's a happy, healthy young man, who exercises daily, plays basketball and soccer.

I personally don't see anything wrong with Jordin. I rather see her the way she is than see her showing off her bones!

di8828 read my blog view my photos
Jun 8, 2007 | 8:52 AM

If you recall their where heavier contestants on American Idol much bigger in the weight area then her too!

Jordin is a big bone, big girl! She is also stil young and has things still to learn...her stardom at her young age will change her given time. She will be so busy now and I believe she will become more into a healthy way of live or be so busy she could damage her health even more like so many other young stars has done! She is young and just starting so she should at least be given a chance first before any judgement is made...Roth is to quick to place judgment upon anybody!

dh1099 read my blog
Jun 8, 2007 | 8:54 AM

I think it is sad that everyone is so weight obsessed. Unless it is her own personal doctor telling her to lose weight for medical reasons I think she should just go on with her life. I think she is a beautiful girl and if she is happy with herself then that is all that matters.

DVS11965 read my blog view my photos
Jun 8, 2007 | 9:02 AM

Do you all honestly believe that Jordan's doctor isn't telling her to lose weight? I'ev never met a dr that wouldn't say to lose weight when you are that big. Awww Jordan can get an eating disorder by going on a diet. LOL that's the best excuse yet to stay overweight...keep em coming.

Just because nothing was said about any other contestant, doesn't mean that Jordon isn't overweight. Remember, admitting a problem is the first step in fixing it. How can anyone say Jordon isn't overweight? Are we talking about the same person.

Do you think if Jordon dropped 50 pounds she would look and feel better? Talk to anyone whose lost a lot of weight and ask them how they feel about themselves now.

Gammies61 read my blog view my photos
Jun 8, 2007 | 10:09 AM

Jordin is 17 years old. If someone put her height, bone mass, and weight into ratios, she might be 10 lbs over. I doubt she is carrying 50 extra pounds. Even Jim Van Fleet looks bigger on TV and he's a tall skinny person. Sorry Jim, but you know it's true.
And as far as Doctors go, most of the time the ones who are obese and headed for a heart attack, are the same ones who tell their patients they need to lose weight.
When I weighed 142, I looked like a walking pile of bony muscle. According to weight charts I should have been 135 lbs.
I think she'll be OK, she's going to be exercising a lot over the next year, and this is the key to staying fit.

jackrabbit read my blog
Jun 8, 2007 | 11:18 AM

If you have two obese people (m&w) and they have kids, the odds of those kids to be obese aswell outweight the odds that they won't be obese. It's all in the genes. CNBC reported this morning that there are 400 million obese people world wide. My answer to that, "help control obesity... spay & neuter!!!"

heatheranders73 view my photos
Jun 8, 2007 | 4:08 PM

I completely agree with Gammie. One can't make an assessment of her health based soley on looking at her on television compared to a very short Ryan Seacrest. (I know him - Trust me, he's short.)

If you were to take all of her physical variables into account, she probably isn't as overweight as it seems. And if so, she's only 17. I myself was overweight for a few years as a teenager, but I grew 2 inches in college, my metabolism (or something!) changed, and have since been (and now am) in normal weight range for my height/age. And healthy the whole time.

i_live_in_kissimmee read my blog view my photos
Jun 8, 2007 | 5:22 PM

Ok.Jordin Sparks is over weight. But she isnt completely FAT. They always have to find something wrong with everybody. She seems nice enough, and she can sing. Its people like her that you should want us kids to look up to! Jordin shows us that even if your a little big you can still be beautiful! Would you want everyone going crazy because they arent Nicole Richie skinny? Being that skinny isnt healthy either so its a lose-lose situation. People like him are always finding something wrong with everybody. I think Jordin Sparks Is a beautiful young woman and people need to back off of her.

Jangel read my blog view my photos
Jun 9, 2007 | 12:14 AM

Jordin looks fine. There are millions of women who whould kill for her figure. She is a woman with curves and most guys my age really dont like the white picket fence look. That lady needs to live and go to Johnny rockets or something. Being fit is not just bout scales and food but being fit is first and for most being fit and comfterble with yourself. Thats the problem with obese children. They lack self cofidence and to see someone they can relate to, be as cofedent and amazing as jordin is... whats wrong with that. Not your body not, your image, not your problem, go be skinny.

Page 1 of 1


Write your comment below:




FOX35News-Mornings

Wake up and get going with the FOX 35 Morning Crew.

Member Since: 11/25/2006